Getting the SEO balance right - writing content for humans

December 16th, 2007

I have disagreed with Andrew Girdwood from BigMouthMedia a couple of times in the past, however I wholeheartedly applauded him on his article on ‘Think of the human. Write for humans!‘, an article tackling the topic of keyword density, and in particular a response to comments by David Cushman and Sean Warwick.

There are a number of pages around that do occupy some reasonable positions for moderately competitive term (studentcomputers is one such term that springs to mind), however for everyone of these keyword laden SEO-targeted pages, there are a number of other well structured and well thought out campaigns that comensate for this (I used the Monarch SEO campaign as well as a couple of our own - Escapes2 for example). However as Andrew states:

“Proper SEO (okay; let’s use the word ‘ethical SEO’) is about ensuring the search engine can see what your site is about. In fact, proper SEO includes basic tips like ensure web page content has an unique URL so communities and forums can link to it (as opposed to an Ajax style or single Flash URL which is used to display all the content). It tends to be the horrid combination of search spam and poor websites which result in Google searchers clicking themselves into a worthless experience.”

However it is Andrews response to Sean Warwicks comments regarding high keyword density pages that I think are absolutely spot on, and I can only aplaud his response

“And lastly, let me respectfully (and pleadingly) reiterate one key point: The fact that you *can* find sites that rank well for a particular keyword engaging in “keyword stuffing” is NOT evidence that such keyword stuffing is an effective SEO tool. I can also show you many sites that use the letter “Q” exactly three times that also rank well. And no, this is not an indication of a secret “jump the ‘q’ rule.”

SEO has come a long long way in 2007, moving from ‘Black Art’ to mainstream marketing with organisations such as Bigmouth, Latitude and JustSearch catapulting SEO into the mainstream. We still have a way to go, however it is the education of people such as David and Sean that will continue to see Online Marketing and Search marketing in particular continue to develop in the long term

Entry Filed under: SEO, Search Marketing